← Back to the category

Consumer disputes, construction and services

A valuable product arrives damaged or different from what you ordered

Goal: link the condition on arrival to your order.

Create an account and start

The problem

When the value or the risk of a dispute justifies a Record, a product arrives damaged, incomplete, used, with a broken seal, as the wrong model or otherwise not as ordered.

Link the unboxing video to the order and the tracking. Keep the shipping label in the lawfully preserved file and protect its personal data in any copies you share. First raise it with the seller and keep their reply; in a consumer dispute, you can also contact the consumer authority or regulator in your country.

Most returns go smoothly. But with expensive products, the shop or seller may ask: did the damage happen after delivery? Was the missing item really not in the box? Without a record of the unboxing, it becomes one version against another.

It doesn't make sense to film every parcel that arrives. It's worth doing when the product's value or the risk of a dispute justifies it.

What to preserve

When proportionate to the value, a continuous unboxing video, photos of the packaging, label, seals, serial number and defect, and your messages to the seller.

Goal: link the condition on arrival to your order.

Main file: the original unboxing video and photos of the packaging.

When to capture: on delivery and when opening it, if safe.

Supporting sources: the order, the tracking and the support reference number.

Limit of this scenario: on its own, the Record does not establish where the damage came from, or whether the carrier or the seller is responsible.

Collect only what you need, through access you are lawfully entitled to. Use neutral file names and descriptions, store files securely and share them only with people who need them. Where it is lawful to make a redacted copy, keep it as a separate file from the preserved original and note which version's hash you registered. See the Privacy Policy.

A continuous video, starting with the sealed box and a readable label, shows the sequence without cuts. Close-ups show the seals, any damage to the packaging and the serial number. Your message or complaint reference to the seller completes the set.

How Provenia documents this scenario

Your browser calculates the SHA-256 hash of the file you select. The file itself stays on your device: Provenia receives only the hash and metadata, meaning the file name, its size and the context fields you fill in. Provenia stores the hash and the Record data. Keep the exact file you used and the exported Dossier, because they are what make a byte-for-byte check possible later.

Three different times are involved. The time the Record was created on Provenia comes from Provenia's server and is not certified. The date of the event or capture is something you declare in the context, in the description or in the file itself, and it depends on other sources. The externally certified UTC date and time ties the hash you submitted to the timestamp authority's response; it does not certify when the event happened.

Provenia sends the hash, never the file, to FreeTSA, an external timestamp authority, which issues an RFC 3161 timestamp. Provenia validates that timestamp before the Record is completed. If FreeTSA is unavailable, or the timestamp cannot be obtained or does not validate, the Record is not created and no credit is used. Older Records created before this feature was active may have no external timestamp. A timestamp obtained today covers the hash submitted today; it is never issued later or backdated.

Each Record's timestamp is separate from the signatures on the exported Dossier: Provenia's digital signature on the PDF and the Ed25519 signature on Dossier.json. Those signatures cover the exported documents and do not certify the date of the event. See Trust and Verifiability.

In this scenario, use the original unboxing video and photos of the packaging as your reference material and check it against the order, the tracking and the support reference number. The timestamp on a hash does not confirm where the damage came from, or whether the carrier or the seller is responsible.

Step by step

  1. First, raise the issue with the seller and keep the reference number and their reply. In a consumer dispute, you can also contact the consumer authority or regulator in your country.
  2. Link the unboxing video to the order and the tracking. Keep the shipping label in the lawfully preserved file and protect its personal data in any copies you share.
  3. Preserve the original unboxing video and photos of the packaging exactly as it is; don't edit the file you register.
  4. Link the material to the order, the tracking and the support reference number; describe its origin and when it was captured as declared information.
  5. Group the milestones in a Project and register each relevant file separately. Keep the files untouched and the exported Dossier, with a secure backup.

What the Record shows and what it does not

A Record is a private electronic document that can form part of a wider body of evidence, assessed according to its context and origin. On its own, it does not establish where the damage came from, or whether the carrier or the seller is responsible. Keep the supporting sources and read the Terms of Use.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to film all my purchases?

No. Do it when the value or the risk of a dispute justifies it.

How should I organize the files for this case?

Register the original video untouched as the main Record, then the close-up photos, and note the order and tracking numbers in the description. If you share a copy with the seller, blur the address on the label in that copy only, and keep it as a separate file from the original.

Which date is certified?

Only the UTC date and time in a valid external RFC 3161 response tied to that Record's hash. The time on Provenia's server and the event or capture date you declare are separate pieces of information. The timestamp does not certify when the event happened.

Official references

Technical reference for context only. It is not legal advice or a conclusion about any case. Provenia is not affiliated with, integrated with or endorsed by the organization listed.

Start with three free credits

Each Record covers one file. Each completed Record uses one credit, including the first one, which creates the Project. A new account includes three free Document Credits and one Project, with no payment and no card, so the starter credits cover three single-file Records. For prices and conditions, see Pricing.

Already have an account? Log in.

Create an account and start

Continue reading